2004
Best World Heavyweight Champion: NFM
Best National Champion: Desiree
Best Newcomer: The Eagle
Feud of the Year: Danny Williams (NWF Owner) & Joseph Duncan (NWF Commissioner)
Match of the Year: Rage In A Double-Cage Match (Season's Beatings): Korvus, Nemesis, Strajk, Syco, and Commissioner Joseph D vs. Ronin BlackKnight, NFM, "The Franchise" John Bane, "Face From The Past", and NWF Owner/CEO Danny Williams
Most Shocking Event: Chushy's Debut in the NWF
Best Female (Wrestler): Desiree
Newcomer Predicted to "Make Waves" in 2005: Chushy
Best Promos: Pete "POz" Osbourne
Wrestler of the Year: NFM
2005
Best World Heavyweight Champion: NFM
Best National Champion: Titan
Best Tag Team Champions: "The Dark Riders" Rohan & Ultraforce
Feud of the Year: Nemesis & MBK
Most Shocking Event: NFM's Revelation as "Nightmare"
Best Promos: "The Hardcore Icon" John Bane
Wrestler Predicted to "Make Waves" for the remainder of 2005: The Eagle
Best Newcomer: "The Natural" Adam Killings
Most Improved Handler: Rohan
Biggest Impact in Recent Weeks: Rohan
Match of the Year: Chamber of Hell Match (Summer Shock 2005): "The Hardcore Icon" John Bane -vs.- "The Main Event" David Strajk
Wrestler of the Year: The Eagle
2006
Best World Television Champion: Nemesis
Best National Champion: "The Future" Adam Killings
Newcomer of the Year: "Adman" Adam Cooper
NPC of the Year: "Da Boss" Danny "D-Will" Williams
Best World Heavyweight Champion: Oni
Most Improved Handler: "The Natural" Jay Aivaz
Best Tag Team Champions: Slim & Ivy
Match of the Year: Six-Man Hell In A Cell for the NWF National Heavyweight Championship (GAME OVER): Mark Cage, "Ace" Rob Smith, "Mr. Unique" Kidman Hardy, The Fallen One, Methane, "The Classy One" Brian
Wrestler of the Year: Oni/Koden
2007
Best Newcomer: Cameron "The Edge" Jackson
Best Returning NWF Superstar: Tie between NFM & Pete "POz" Osbourne
Most Improved Handler: Phoenix
Best World Television Champion: "Bombshell" Erik Quick
Best NPC: Blake James
Best XTREME Champion: NFM
Best Tag Team: "KO" Kerry Owens & "Bombshell" Erik Quick
Best National Champion: Slim
Most Gracious Handler: Slim
Best World Heavyweight Champion: Pete "POz" Osbourne
Match of the Year: Tie Between (both from Spring Fever '07) World Tag Team Championship Scaffold Match: Phoenix & Damon -vs.- Blake Styles & Dragon De Plata and Retirement Match: Pete "POz" Osbourne -vs.- Danny "D-Will" Williams
Storyline of the Year: POz returning to the NWF as "???"
Wrestler of the Year: Hardy
2008
Most Gracious Handler: Dragon De Plata
Tag Team Champions of the Year: Phoenix & Naron
Best XTREME Champion: Cameron "The Edge" Jackson
NPC of the Year: The Godfather
Most Improved Handler: Matt Logan
Best United States Champion: Dragon De Plata
Comeback Wrestler of the Year: "KO" Kerry Owens
Most Shocking Moment: Tie Between Matt Logan winning NWF WHC & D-Will revealing himself as Slim's stalker
Best World Heavyweight Champion: Slim
Match of the Year: Eight-Person Terror Cage Match (4th Anniversary Show)
Wrestler of the Year: Slim
2009
Best Heel: Nubis
Best Face: Pimp D
Best Tag Team Champions: Phoenix & Naron
Best Nobles Champion: Scott Jamin
Best XTREME Champion: Dave Kipfer
Best United States Champion: Nubis
Best World Heavyweight Champion: Slim
Match of the Year: Terror Cage Match for the NWF World Heavyweight Championship (Season's Beatings V): Kerry Owens -vs.- The Eagle -vs.- Nubis -vs.- Meth -vs.- Raelin Phoenix -vs.- Slim
PPV of the Year: NWF Season's Beatings V
Most Shocking Moment: NFM taking control of the NWF after D-Will sells him a 'time share' of the company
Wrestler of the Year: Tie between Dave Kipfer & Pimp D
2010
Best NPC: Danny "D-Will" Williams
Best Face: "The Hunter" Yoshi Hoshino
Best Tweener: Raelin Phoenix
Best Heel: "Dynamite" David Reznik
Best Secondary Champion: Dave Kipfer
Best World Heavyweight Champion: Improv
Best Newcomer: Improv
Match of the Year: Champion vs. Champion: Two Out of Three Falls (NWF Alpha): Raelin Phoenix -vs.- Dave Kipfer
Wrestler of the Year: Improv
